Chat rooms vs Twitter: how I communicate now


CC0, Pixabay

This time last year, Brad Colbow published a comic in his “The Brads” series entitled “The long slow death of Twitter”. It really encapsulates the way I’ve been feeling about Twitter for a while now.

Go ahead and take a look. I’ll still be here when you come back.

According to my Twitter profile, I joined in February 2009 as user #20,049,102. It was nearing its 3rd birthday and, though there were clearly a lot of people already signed up at that point, it was still relatively quiet, especially in the UK.

I was a lonely PhD student just starting to get interested in educational technology, and one thing that Twitter had in great supply was (and still is) people pushing back the boundaries of what tech can do in different contexts.

Somewhere along the way Twitter got really noisy, partly because more people (especially commercial companies) are using it more to talk about stuff that doesn’t interest me, and partly because I now follow 1,200+ people and find I get several tweets a second at peak times, which no-one could be expected to handle. More recently I’ve found my attention drawn to more focussed communities instead of that big old shouting match.

I find I’m much more comfortable discussing things and asking questions in small focussed communities because I know who might be interested in what. If I come across an article about a cool new Python library, I’ll geek out about it with my research software engineer friends; if I want advice on an aspect of my emacs setup, I’ll ask a bunch of emacs users.

I feel like I’m talking to people who want to hear what I’m saying. Next to that experience, Twitter just feels like standing on a street corner shouting.

IRC channels (mostly on Freenode), and similar things like Slack and gitter form the bulk of this for me, along with a growing number of WhatsApp group chats. Although online chat is theoretically a synchronous medium, I find that I can treat it more as “semi-synchronous”: I can have real-time conversations as they arise, but I can also close them and tune back in later to catch up if I want. Now I come to think about it, this is how I used to treat Twitter before the 1,200 follows happened.

I also find I visit a handful of forums regularly, mostly of the Reddit link-sharing or StackExchange Q&A type. /r/buildapc was invaluable when I was building my latest box, /r/EarthPorn (very much not NSFW) is just beautiful.

I suppose the risk of all this is that I end up reinforcing my own echo chamber. I’m not sure how to deal with that, but I certainly can’t deal with it while also suffering from information overload.


You can respond to this post, "Chat rooms vs Twitter: how I communicate now", by: liking, boosting or replying to a tweet or toot that mentions it; or sending a webmention from your own site to

Comments & reactions haven't loaded yet. You might have JavaScript disabled but that's cool 😎.


Powered by Cactus Comments 🌵